Commander for under £100: mission impossible or a challenge worth accepting? The honest answer is: it depends on how you build. The Commander format has a reputation for being a money-eating machine, but if you look at the most-played Commanders right now — from Witherbloom, the Balancer to Killian, Decisive Mentor, by way of Isshin, Two Heavens as One — you'll notice that many of the most enjoyable and competitive decks don't necessarily call for a second mortgage. What you do need is to know where to cut and where not to compromise.
Choosing the right Commander: the foundation of everything
The first mistake almost everyone makes is choosing the Commander they like best aesthetically and then building the deck around whatever budget is left over. It works the other way round: with a limited budget, you need to choose a Commander whose game plan doesn't rely on hugely expensive single cards to function.
Among the most-played Commanders at the moment, some lend themselves to a budget approach better than others. Killian, Decisive Mentor, for example, rewards a strategy built around Auras and spells that target creatures — cards that tend to come at a very modest price because they're plentiful in every set. The deck is built around synergies of common and uncommon cards, leaving the few extra pounds for a handful of essential rares.
Prismari, the Inspiration, on the other hand, pushes towards powerful, spectacular spells, but be careful: "spectacular" in Commander often means "expensive". Not impossible to build on a budget, but it calls for more care in card selection.
The general principle is simple: choose a Commander whose text already sets out a clear direction on its own, so that every card you add is part of the plan rather than a generic "good Commander card" that costs you ten pounds purely for being good everywhere.
How to spread your budget: the practical rule
With £100, a sensible split is this: dedicate roughly a third of the budget (£30-35) to lands. You don't need the perfect manabase with fetches and original dual lands, but a few lands that enter untapped or produce the right colours are non-negotiable. A wonky manabase sinks even the most synergistic deck in the world.
The remaining budget goes on the engine of the deck: the cards that carry forward the plan of your chosen Commander. If you play Isshin, Two Heavens as One — which doubles the effects of attack "triggers" — invest in creatures with powerful effects when they attack. Many of these cost next to nothing and, in a dedicated deck, become disproportionately strong.
Where you can, save on the generic "loners": mass card draw, low-cost removal, ramp with basic lands. Commander is a format where synergies often beat individual powerful cards — a cohesive £80 deck regularly beats a random collection of £300 worth of staples.
Another practical tip: look at Commanders like Ashling, the Limitless or Y'shtola, Night's Blessed — decks built around them often exploit repeatable, synergistic mechanics that don't require legendary £20-a-piece rarities to tick over. Study how these decks work in the community, then adapt the structure to your budget by cutting the most expensive cards and looking for functionally similar alternatives at a lower price.
The truth nobody says often enough: in casual and semi-competitive Commander, the player who knows their own deck inside out almost always wins over someone who has spent more without a clear plan.
Hi, I'm Fabrizio! I hope this article has given you a few ideas for your next deck. If you'd like to dig deeper, find the cards you're missing or simply have a game, drop by Timetwister Games in Bolzano — we've got Standard, Commander and everything you need to play seriously. See you soon! 🧙
Find it at Timetwister Games
Looking for a Magic: The Gathering booster box, starter deck or preorder? Browse the whole Magic: The Gathering section on our online store or pop into our shop in Bolzano.